4 vanilla cupcakes with white frosting and red/white/blue sprinkles with square cupcake toppers on toothpicks: I Voted (so I deserve a cupcake), Future Voter, My Mom Voted, My Dad Voted, on white platter in front of blue ombre pumpkins

Printable Election Day Cupcake Toppers for a Bake Sale

12 Shares

Bake sales are a tried-and-true fundraising method. Since the baked goods are donated, all the proceeds go towards the cause. In just a few short hours, hundreds of dollars can be raised. One common bake sale opportunity is on Election Day since polls are typically open all day. To make your goodies even more tempting, you can easily make these Election Day printable cupcake toppers. They take a generic cupcake and turn it into something Instagrammable!

[My blog posts contain affiliate links. These don’t cost you anything, but they allow me to continue running this site and providing free content for my readers. Full disclosure here.]

Bake Sale Success 101

Pricing

The first time I participated in a bake sale was in college. A club I belonged to was raising money by selling baked goods in the cafeteria during lunch. At first, I thought that college kids wouldn’t really want to buy much since they are typically short on cash. Boy, was I wrong! I found that they craved homemade goodies, and would come back for seconds (and thirds) of the pumpkin bread I had made. (Thanks to my Junior High Home Economics teacher for an easy, quickbread recipe for that one!)

At that bake sale, we had a “pay what you want” pricing structure. Most people went above and beyond and paid us more than what I would have picked as the price. So we were able to raise a decent amount of money in just a couple of hours.

Portioning and Packaging

Since then, I have participated in dozens more bake sales by contributing baked goods. I find that people typically want single-serving-size items, so it is helpful to individually package each item. For most types of cookies, that means two or three cookies in a treat bag. If you are selling cupcakes, these clear cupcake containers are ideal. They snap securely shut, and don’t require assembly like the cardboard cupcake boxes do. Plus, since they are completely see-through, it is easy for the customer to see what they are getting.

Having pre-wrapped servings is definitely more hygienic as well since the volunteers handling the money are not also touching the food. In this day and age, your customers will appreciate that! 

Rows of Red velvet cupcakes with vanilla swirl frosting and red/white/blue sprinkles in individual clear containers and sign that says Red velvet cupcakes with vanilla buttercream

If customers are buying several items, it is helpful to have bags for them to carry their items home. It can be as simple as brown paper lunch bags. (If it is a fundraiser for a school, have the kids write thank you notes on the outside of the bags. It adds a nice added touch, while also teaching them to show gratitude!)

Allergy-Safe Options

Unfortunately, at a bake sale stocked with donated items, it is almost impossible to guarantee that items are allergen-safe. Even if someone did not use nuts in their baked goods, their kitchen might still have had traces of nuts in it, so you can’t take the chance. I will never forget the bake sale we had on Pi Day one year when a family donated a pie they had purchased at a supermarket bakery. They attached a handwritten note saying it “might have been made in a facility that contains nuts.” Well, it was a pecan pie, so it goes without saying that it contained nuts!

If you do wish to offer allergen-safe options, your best bet is to buy commercially prepared and packaged items that are clearly labeled as allergen-free. People with allergies would feel more comfortable buying brands they are familiar with, as long as they are still individually sealed. 

Beverage Bar

As people have become more health-conscious over the years, they might not be interested in eating any baked goods. However, if you offer beverage options as well, you can still make a sale. It could be as simple as setting up a coffee maker and providing an assortment of dairy options. If you get a variety pack of single-serve coffee pods, customers might be willing to try out a new flavor since they are only buying one cup rather than investing in a whole box of a specialty flavor. 

For the tea drinkers, set up an electric kettle for boiling water, and put out an assortment of tea bags. You could also have packets of instant hot cocoa mix on hand since those are always a hit with children.

Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert

If your bake sale is going to be held over a longer period of time (such as longer than two hours) it is a good idea to have an assortment of goodies. People don’t necessarily want to buy items with frosting at 7:00 a.m. But they would buy muffins or slices of banana bread at that hour. Once you get past lunch, that is when the cupcakes and cookies will become big sellers.

Signage 

Think about the coffee shops you frequent and how they display their baked goods. They typically will have little signs in front of each tray so that customers know what it is without having to ask. Similar signs are especially useful at a bake sale, where the people staffing the table are generally not the same people who baked the items. The signs can be as simple as an index card folded in half with the name of the item printed neatly in bold letters. 

If you are charging different prices for different goodies, make sure to put the price on the sign as well. It is helpful to also put the name of the item and the price on the back of the sign. That way, the people working at the table can easily add up the prices.

Rows of red velvet cupcakes and apple cider cupcakes on turquoise tablecloth with yellow heart shaped price tags

Election Day Cupcakes

The school at which I teach has a bake sale on Election Day as a fundraiser for our 5th grade. Since voting takes place in our school buildings, the students have off that day for security reasons. Several of their families volunteer to work shifts at the bake sale. The kids make excellent salespeople, as who can resist when a friendly ten-year-old entices you to buy homemade cookies?

I typically make my red velvet sour cream cupcakes with vanilla buttercream frosting. (The recipes are at the bottom of those linked pages.)  I add red, white, and blue sprinkles to make them even more patriotic for the occasion. 

Red velvet sour cream cupcakes start out with a boxed cake mix, but with a few easy add-ins, will taste homemade. They are great for Election Day, Memorial Day, 4th of July, or Labor Day.

Making Election Day Cupcake Toppers

I have noticed that for the past few years, people have been posting pictures of their “I Voted” stickers on social media on Election Day. That gave me the idea to create Election Day printable cupcake toppers that are easy to make. Print them using either an inkjet or color laser printer onto plain white cardstock. Since I designed them as rectangles, you can easily cut them out with scissors or a paper cutter

Election Day Cupcake toppers being cut on a Fiskars 12 inch paper cutter with scissors next to it
A 12-inch paper cutter makes quick work out of making neat edges on each cupcake topper, but scissors can be used instead.

The easiest way to assemble them is to use double-sided tape to attach a toothpick to the center back of the design. Put another small piece of double-sided tape along the right edge of the back. Then fold the cardstock in half to create the Election Day printable cupcake topper

blank side of cupcake topper with toothpick and double sided tape
Attach a toothpick with double-sided tape at the center of the reverse side of the front of the design. Put another piece of tape on the right side so that when the piece is folded over, it will be sealed shut.

If you don’t have double-sided tape and are using glue instead, be very careful not to get ANY glue on the part of the toothpick that will be inserted into the cupcake. 

Use either wood skewers or lollipop sticks that are cut to size if you want your topper to be taller. 

wood toothpicks, skewers, and lollipop sticks
Regular toothpicks work fine with the height of most icing designs. You can also use wooden skewers or lollipop sticks that have been trimmed to the desired length.

If you are putting the cupcakes into the clear containers, do not put the toppers in ahead of time. They will not fit into the container. Instead, you can hand them out separately. Or, you can sell them as an “extra” to raise even more money for your cause.

Red velvet cupake with white swirl frosting and red, white & blue sprinkles and cupcake topper that says "I Voted! (So I deserve a cupcake)

Promoting Your Bake Sale

It’s all about social media when it comes to spreading the word on the day of the bake sale. Take closeup photos of each goodie and post them on the organization’s social media pages, along with the details of the hours the bake sale is taking place.

As items sell out, add a “Sold Out” graphic to the photo and post it to social media again. That way, your potential customers will know to come down sooner rather than later to get the items they want. 

If you have any artists in your organization, consider making a photo backdrop for the occasion. Your customers can snap photos of themselves at your bake sale. If they post it on their own social media pages, they will be helping to spread the word about your fundraiser.

The aroma of freshly brewed coffee will entice customers to venture on over to the bake sale. This can be especially helpful on Election Day, as some people vote on their way to work and might not have time to make a separate stop at their usual coffee shop. They will appreciate being able to multi-task as they vote!

I would love to hear if you use these at an Election Day Bake Sale. Please share your bake sale tips in the comment section below!

Pin Image of 3 vanilla cupcakes with white icing and red/white/blue cupcake toppers that say I Voted, My Dad Voted, Future Voter, on red plate with text overaly of Printable Election Day Cupcake Toppers and teacherbakermaker.com
Pin image of 6 cupcake toppers on toothpicks that read I Voted (So I Deserve a Cupcake), My Dad Voted, My Mom Voted, and Future Voter with text overlay of Election Day Bake Sale Cupcake Toppers and Printable and teacherbakermaker.com

12 Shares

5 Responses

    1. There is a chocolate and cake decorating supply store locally that sells them, but it looks like Amazon has the better price. They are great to have on hand at parties for people to take home the leftover cupcakes. At a public bake sale, they not only keep the cupcakes from getting stale, but it is so much more sanitary than random people touching the baked goods!

  1. What a fun idea and one that can be applied to any special day! Thank you for explaining this process, the toppers look great and I could see it making an event more special. Shows dedication.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Welcome with head shot

Hi, I'm Maureen!

I help fellow teachers, home bakers, and crafters learn new skills so that they can build their self-confidence in their talents. 

Learn more about me and how I can help you here.

Let's Connect!

Get My Newsletter

12 Shares
Share
Pin12